Credits Director/Scenario/: Narration: Dan Tschernia Participant: Johan Otto von Spreckelsen:
Catalog number #764
45 minutes Color
Age Range: 15 to Adult
Closed Captions and Interactive Transcript
Filmscape Adobe Flash Required. See more
48hr Streaming Access
Loading the player...
SPRECKELSEN: I like there to be a difference between public buildings and the house you live in yourself. I couldn't imagine my own house as a monument, nor could I imagine a large housing complex as being monumental, I react quite violently to it, that's not what people want, and if people want symbols let them have national symbols which they can go and visit if they feel the need. The other point is, it's wrong, and there must be a difference between the things you come in contact with every day and the things you visit when you go to the opera or an exhibition, or visit the cube, where everything to do with the future, with communication, with culture, with art, and so on, takes place.
SPEAKER: Johan Otto von Spreckelsen was born on 4th May 1929. In 1953, at the age of 24, he qualified as an architect. In 1978 he was appointed Professor in the architectural faculty at the Academy of Art. He won a number of competitions in both Denmark and Sweden, one of which was the State Art Foundation's competition for town planning in 1967. SPRECKELSEN: Of course, these models can be characterized as architectural fantasies, but, er, we have worked with it seriously and realistically. And there is nothing to prevent them being used as a basis for further design. And in that way show that there is a bit more to it than playing with shapes. They can be built traditionally, they can be built using industrial techniques, on the spot, they can be pre-fabricated. But obviously we can't plan it all since it would take several years to work out. SPEAKER: West of Paris is the modern quarter known as La Defense. In 1982, the President of France, Francois Mitterand announced a competition for ideas as to how the complex could be completed. Mitterand chose the winner in May, 1983. It was the Danish architect, Johan Otto von Spreckelsen
SPRECKELSEN: In Paris, here where the Seine runs through Paris like this, here we have an axis, an historic axis, there, here we have the Louvre, la Cour Carree, here we have La Place de la Concorde, here we have the large Arc de Triomphe. And over here we have La Defense. Everyone who has been to Paris, or even anyone who hasn't, knows that the characteristic symbol of Paris is the Eiffel Tower. It looks like this, and they know that there is something called Sacre Coeur. It looks like this. And then there is a little bit, and you go in here, and there are some big stairs there, and they know there are things called Arcs de Triomphe, and they look like all other triumphal arches and there is a thing like that with a hole in it, and there is something called Centre Pompidou, it looks like this, and then there is that big fellow there. See, the funny thing about all these buildings is that none of them has anything to do with Paris, so the things which are characteristic for Paris are those things you normally wouldn't find in Paris, and there aren't two of those things, either, and there are so many other things there, it's funny really, because if you make a character sketch of a town it's usually something to do with its different quarters, their housing and all kinds of other things, but Paris is strange in that regard, and this is one of the things which struck me when I came out to look at the plot here, that all the things we know of are different from everything else to do with Paris, and so I thought that if they wanted something new, a new monument, I must think of something which had nothing to do with Paris, and they didn't have a cube down there, so I thought, "they'd better have a cube", and so now we have got one of those, too. It looks like that, that thing there. SPEAKER: Spreckelsen's winning project was a cube, a beautiful marble-clad building at the end of what Parisians call "The Historic Axis" from the Louvre, through the Place de la Concorde to the Arc de Triomphe and then further out towards the west. SPRECKELSEN: In the autumn of 1982 the French State announced a competition for a new monument, an international center for communication. It was a handsome slogan, it was announced in all the media and lots of architects took part, and others, engineers, philosophers, what do I know, landscape architects, and so on, because it was a very tempting competition, partly since it is incredibly inspiring to work with something in Paris, and partly because the idea of an international communications center was also incredibly inspiring to work with, so I was captivated by the idea of this project. I started on it early, in the autumn of '82, and er, as you often do, I tried various things, but there was something strangely fascinating about that cube which kept returning to me, I don't know why, but I couldn't really get get rid of it, so in January my wife and I went down to Paris to see this marvelous site, it was terrible. This place here, called La Defense, means defense, they once defended themselves against the Germans there; it doesn't have anything to do with Paris either, so it will probably become a characteristic symbol, a kind of town with only large office blocks, some with horizontal stripes and some with vertical stripes, and some have stripes which go vertically and horizontally. The studio we lived in, it was tiny, had them like that. And then there are others which are much taller and black, there are others which just have holes, like in the old days and then there are these odd large halls which are also out there, and it's a strange thing to come out there. When you look from Paris you can see the tall skyscrapers which have nothing to do with Paris, but neither do they have anything to do with New York, it's a work, a work which is just as daring and just as brutal as everything else which symbolizes Paris. If you go out there in the summer, at five in the morning, when everything is quiet, and the morning sun is shining on it, then the whole thing is pink, a very pretty color, and the rest is blue-grey and black, absolutely here, there is actually a crematorium here, and in the morning you can smell bodies here, it is an incredible sight, and the really dramatic thing and that inspires something. Because the first time we came down here we were on the point of giving up, it was just at the beginning of February, and it was windy, and it was, yes, what was it, it was a Saturday morning, or it was a Sunday morning, I can't remember, there wasn't a soul about, it was like watching a Fellini film, my wife and I walked about, just as quietly, completely alone, on this huge promenade, which is 300 meters long and 100 meters wide, and these enormous buildings standing there, that you can't relate to anything, 100 meters up, er, 100 meters, no, it must be 200 meters, 200 meters together, all that is just too much, and there the two of us strolled, until we came to the hole, a huge hole, that was the site, and it was anything but inspirational, we couldn't get any coffee either, we couldn't get anything. Yes, we found a small, small snack bar on the corner where we sat down and had a cup of coffee, and there I sketched my chilly little cube on the serviette and thought, "It still doesn't matter, because that place there, you can put anything there, no argument, so I became more convinced in my belief that when I saw that awful place, nothing I did could be any worse than what was already there, which shows how lucky you can be as an architect. Just think if it had been an attractive plot, naturally beautiful with a wonderful view and all that, eh, but it wasn't. SPRECKELSEN: Of course I was happy and surprised, it's nice to win a first prize, so, er, we went down there quickly, and of course the place looked entirely different when we got there, it was spring, the sun was shining and there were loads of people. It had never been as beautiful. But everything happened so fast that we were completely unprepared, there was a big press conference we arrived at, and about 150 journalists were sitting waiting, you know them, and fortunately they were so friendly, that they allowed the other prizewinners to come out first, first the buyers, that was over quickly, then the third prize winners, who had prepared, they were Canadians, they came and presented their project really well, and then they said that they had also built so many schools, several thousand flats, and they had built factories there, and they had companies all over the world, and I said it sounded very interesting, and then came the next prizewinners, and they said that they had built so many things there, they had built so many homes, and new urban areas there, and restored buildings there, and factories there, agricultural things, development projects and all that, and finally they came to me. And, I said it as it was, that I was, that I thought this cube was, was just the right thing for them there, and they cheered at that. They liked that, they don't need reasons, Frenchmen, you just say it's a cube they need, and then they all clapped, but then something terrible happened, one of them asked "well, what else have you done as an architect?", and so I just said "I've done four churches and my own house", and then they all clapped and cheered, they were absolutely delighted, and I couldn't really understand it, until I visited the embassy later in the day, and they said "they think you were being modest", that I hadn't mentioned all the houses, I hadn't said anything about all those schools, that everything between the four churches and my house was just too much to include, that I was a great architect who just mentioned the extremes, you see. It was great. Later on I told them how it was, and they, they still thought it was really interesting, and funny, that I hadn't built more, but that's the truth. SPRECKELSEN: Yes, I have designed it all, it must all be a part of a whole, if you want a strong room the architect must be the person who is responsible for all design, and if you can work together with the artists, organ-builders, carpenters, bricklayers, and so on, who are doing all this at an early stage you can go far, I can influence all this to a certain point, I need to work with the craftsmen at an early stage, I need to work with the artist at an early stage, in this case it is Thue Poulsen who made the ceramic altar, font and pulpit and Frobenius, who built a very fine, interesting organ, perhaps one of the best organs we have in Denmark.
SPRECKELSEN: I need to know exactly what an organ is, I need to know how much space it takes. I need to know how far I can go before it becomes difficult to construct, but an organ is like a big orchestra, there are many ways of instrumenting it, there are many ways of setting it up, and you can achieve a great deal if you follow the relatively few rules which exist, and I don't think that any two organs are the same, and the organ here in Vangede is an organ which belongs in this room and will not be found anywhere else, so it's a part of the architecture. SPRECKELSEN: Just as our four children are so different, so are my four churches just as different, but they still belong to the same family. SPRECKELSEN: The size of the room means a lot for the final experience and the final appearance you can give a room which is, shall we say, a largish church. The whole point is to take advantage of the special opportunities which a room which is only fairly large presents, and some of them are really good, for example, because of the lack of distance in here you can always see the expression on the faces of the people in the room, even if some of them are sitting in the back row, or in the middle or out at the sides, that means that the vicar is always in contact with all the parishioners, that's very important, the size of the room, it's about 18 times 18 meters, and when you know that, you can start to design the room around it. The whole basis is the human proportions, distance, how far speech can reach, and how much the eye can see, then you as an architect will start to work on this, but these are the basic points. What matters so much is to create a feeling of peace and rest, so that if you are in here, it could be to a service, a wedding or perhaps a church recital, or if you're just alone in here, the room should be at peace, without being boring, without being indifferent, and that is where the art lies for an architect, to bring the room in balance, and here, daylight is incredibly important. If you can get it to play in and bring life to the room, whether the day is sunny or grey, or the light is reflecting from the snow outside, or the drifting clouds, then, with such a pale stone as has been used here, the light can change it from a warm gold to nearly a chilly blue-grey. It's possible you can see it in the picture, I don't know, but it gives a room life. If at the same time you can get the nuances of light and shade which this room provides because of the pillars and because of the sloping walls, you will see that the room is both at peace and has a life of its own at the same time, and that's very important. If you take the easy way out you would be able to hold church services and nothing more, that - that's not enough for me, I can't just build a church around the ritual of the church service, it's a functional program with many solutions. If I'm to design a church as a church, then Christianity must be the basis for it but - there is something uncompromising about Christianity, in fact I can't imagine myself doing a - a church with something or other special about it, so that for most people there isn't anything sacred in the room, and by "sacred" people probably mean something supernatural, and I think that would have an, er, theatrical effect, and as an architect I can't play on that in a church, I might be able to do it other places, but here it was Christianity I wanted to reflect in the architecture, there I had to take something quite clear and beyond discussion as my starting point, and that's the way I work, it's a long, long process and not until all the stones are finally in place in the room do I feel a certain satisfaction in having - having completed a piece of architecture so that I know it contains peace, I know that Christianity is the background for it all, I know that it will be able to last through the years, and that is more or less the philosophy behind this and you can go and find out why it has become what it is now later on. TSCHERNIA: It is vital for you that it's Christianity. What if they came and asked you to build a mosque? SPRECKELSEN: Oh I don't know if I can, I don't know, I would probably be able to get involved in a lot of it, if I really can feel something deeply for it, yes perhaps it probably has something to do with one's tolerance as one grows older, and I grew up as a Christian, but I can tolerate other religions more and more, because, er, that's the only way we can live together on this earth, and it's possible that I could feel a lot of sympathy for other religions without becoming deeply involved in them, I can't exclude the fact that I might have the opportunity to build a mosque or something like that. SPRECKELSEN: I place music higher than architecture. It is a - the perfect abstraction within the world of art, an art form which can repeat itself for hundreds of years, an art form which gives the performer, the one performing the music, a chance of advancing in his understanding of it. One thing is that you have the composer, another thing is that you have the musician, and there you can come much, much further than in other art forms, so it's possible that I would rank architecture as number 2, or perhaps the art of the pastry cook, I haven't decided yet.
TSCHERNIA: As number 2?
SPRECKELSEN: AS NUMBER 2.
TSCHERNIA: What would you put as number 3 or 4? SPRECKELSEN: Then I think all the visual arts would come next, because they have so much to do with architecture. I haven't decided yet. TSCHERNIA: Where is literature, theatre, film? SPRECKELSEN: Oh, it changes all the time, I haven't given numbers, it suddenly gets to be too much but, er, the time I have left over, and the time which inspires me, has a lot to do with music. Not only can I relax when I am watching or experiencing music, I am also inspired. I don't know how the two things are connected but it means a lot.
SPRECKELSEN: When the competition was announced, I think it was in October 82, 1 started straight away, which means that I thoroughly read through the entire program, you read it through, you learn it off by heart, so that you can just get going with your sketches. SPRECKELSEN: There is something called the little Arc de Triomphe, it's something like this, there is something or other flying round up here, some kind of medallion, that's the one down by the gardens, it's 25 x 25 meters and you can see the big Arc de Triomphe through it, first comes the entire complex behind the trees here, and then comes the big Arc de Triomphe, which is a big thing like this. Incidentally another one was built as a model to a scale of 1:1 to make sure that it looked magnificent enough. Well, I did suggest it, but they didn't go for it. That's the big Arc de Triomphe, there some, some large women, lying here, and then some men lying underneath with helmets on and, I don't know why, a big thing there, it's 50 times 50, so I thought it would funny if the next one was 100 x 100. And so it was. This we can see from there. There we can see it's a bit bigger. Then there's that thing there. And the President was very anxious to see what it would look like, all the way through, along the holy axis, sorry, the historical axis. So they made model photographs of the whole thing there and a photomontage. It was interesting for us to see what the whole walk would look like. And a fortunate thing happened. If we take the Arc de Triomphe, here, and the Champs Elysees, here, and then it continues through to La Defense out here. If you walk here you can see through the big Arc de Triomphe, here, there is the cube, rising up and when to get closer to the Arc de Triomphe the cube disappears, and just as you get to the Arc de Triomphe, it's gone. What luck! You just see the big hole there, which they love down there, they love that. Poof! It's gone! And when you come up, "Whoop", it says, and then it's there. And then it stays there. And then you can go all the way down to the Champs de Gaulle, or whatever it's called, and the de Gaulle thing, and then you get to the cube. Now it doesn't move, now it stays there.
Anyway, I told the President, but he wasn't satisfied with that. So we had a model made of the top bit of the cube and they lifted it up. Reitzel took part in what's now called "the great lift". He has written about it, so you know about it. One day .when the weather was still, this giant crane of 150 meters brought up from Marseille, a German system with which to make the plates hang where they should. Everything was done in time. In the course of 4-5 days they had done the lot, and then they hauled it up, this giant crane lifted it and 4 small cranes steered it so that it wouldn't blow away if a sudden wind blew. If wind strikes one of these it can come up in quite a speed. It was raised one afternoon and a call was made to the President, and I hurried down there in a taxi and arrived out here. Oh, he said, is it up there, he said, yes, it's up there, I said, and then he rushed through the garden and said to that security guard there, open up, he said to the guard, he dropped his rifle and ran into that hut and got, the key out and came back again, he was completely confused, and then went out and stood in the middle of the street outside Ronde de Pont in all the traffic there stood the President and the interpreter, and me and a couple more. After a while the security people arrived and were placed around there, and the President said, "This is the safest place of all, nobody knows that I'm standing out here, it hasn't been announced anywhere, I'm not at all nervous," he said, and there we stood, all shouting to each other, because there was a terrific row from all the cars, and the interpreter, who had a weak voice, was almost unable to scream so that he could hear him. "What are you saying?" he said, and so we stood shouting to each other there, then he said "It's blue", he said, so I said "Yes, it's blue" I said, "because it's the afternoon and the evening sun comes in from here, so it's blue," I said, "But early tomorrow it will be pink" I told him, "Oh", he said, "It's pink in the morning?" "Yes". So we got it up the following morning, before he went out to the airport on a state visit or somewhere, it was hauled up again, and it was pink. I was thrilled! VOICE: The President of the Republic SPRECKELSEN: This project bears a lot of resemblance to the project which the President chose.
SPRECKELSEN: If you would like an impression, if I may be so bold as to suggest that you can get the best impression of the proportions if you look from here.
Then you can see that it is at just the right height in relation to the cube (French interpreter) and the clouds take the starkness out of the change to THE SMALL CUBES SPRECKELSEN: He is very clear, very precise, and at the same time he is a wonderfully warm person, and I have the feeling that if he feels attracted by some project it is because they bear some relation to his own general ideals, and not just within the area of art; perhaps it is difficult to explain but it's my impression, after my conversations with him, that he feels very involved in this project, he knows a lot about the cube, he asks questions which show me that he is involved in the project. TSCHERNIA: How many of Mitterand's ideas do you think are the same as the cube's?
SPRECKELSEN: Yes that, outwardly a little formal, perhaps a bit dry, but then there is the pleasant surprise of actually getting inside the person or the cube, and then a number, a number of things appear. He can, I wouldn't say he can play both roles, oh, that's wrong, but he is, he is more or less two people, he is still the Sun King, there is no doubt that they want him to be the Sun King, but on the other hand he is still a delightful person, when you sit down and talk to him, it is very attractive.
I'd like to know how many statesmen in top positions are still able to be, I was about to say, nice people in real life too, It is quite fantastic to experience it. So if the cube reflects this, it will in any case, I think, have granted some of that he sees in the cube, there's no doubt about that. SPRECKELSEN: There is one problem which must be solved soon. If the marble should be surface-treated or if it should be left natural. MITTERAND: Everything depends on what people who know about it say. Will the marble will be too fragile, too brittle to withstand the vagaries of the weather?
SPRECKELSEN: There are two types of experts.
SPRECKELSEN: One type consists of people who have worked with marble from generation to generation, and know when they have a good marble and a bad marble. MITTERAND: Yes, of course, there are monuments made of marble that have resisted for centuries, when they haven't been vandalized, naturally. SPRECKELSEN: The marble we have found is good enough, so they say, not to need any treatment.
Even if there is a lot of acid in the air its surface will still be strong because the crystals are very close together. The other group of experts is those who work in laboratories and do experiments. And they would like to recommend a surface treatment. MITTERAND: What kind of treatment? SPRECKELSEN: It's a surface-treatment which closes the pores of the marble so that water can't come in.
And I'm a bit worried about that because then the stone can't breathe and develop its own natural patina. But of course I will listen to both experts and find the right solution. MITTERAND: Stone is stone. If you change its character, you no longer get the evolution over the ages that you expect of it. And as to the question of how we know whether the marble will be able to resist the ravages of time, there are sufficient examples to allow us to consider that this has been demonstrated. On condition, of course, that the marble was well-chosen. SPRECKELSEN: Anyway, it will take at least a couple of hundred years before we see any damage. MITTERAND: Yes, yes. But we are working for quite a few centuries to come. SPRECKELSEN: I would just like to show you, if I may, the chamfer on the stone, there is a little chamfer of about 2.5 mm. SPRECKELSEN: Which means that we can manage with a join only of 2-3 mm in all. MITTERAND: Yes, in other words they'll be good craftsmen if they can do that.
SPRECKELSEN: Now we've lived here for about 6 months, and then, for some strange reason, you get to like it. Oh, I don't like it because it's particularly attractive, and there's not much life out here either, but, oh, you get some sort of personal relationship with this kind of - of area, when you have to go out each day, you get to know some people, some you like, you say "Hello" to a few every morning, you eat in some of the same places each day, Oh it's become a kind of second home to us.
TSCHERNIA: What do you think of the architecture out here?
SPRECKELSEN: Well, it's a mixed blessing, oh it reflects what has happened quite well, it's everyone's fight against everyone else, it's multinational companies, it's banks, and it's big, powerful finance houses, there's not much housing out here, and each one needs to be better than the other, and that's what you see around here, both good and bad, some things are done very elegantly, others are not quite as elegant, but it's one colossal mix-up -1 would say that it's both, what could you call it, it's both fascinating and, at the same time, awful, oh you have that strange division between something you can't - can't resist, because of the power displayed around here, and when you look at it as an architect you ask "Does it have to look like this?", but it is reality and I accept it, these are my neighbors, they must be members of the cube's family so you must like them or you won't get anything positive out of it, and that's the attitude we have developed the last few years. Look at the site we're building on, you have probably got the impression that it's not the nicest, but now comes the worst thing - the site has a funny shape, the axis which runs through it, smoothly and quietly, and then the site has this kind of shape, it goes up there, and then it goes out here and then there, and so it's a long site of about 300 metres here, here is West and her - it's towards Paris isn't it, we are right out at the end of the complex, and that innocent-looking thing over there, that's the ring-road running round there, it's known as the half-moon, and a large, 300 meter wide area, 100 meters in that direction, it's called P. Its a kind of waiting room to Paradise, as it's called, but this down here underneath it goes, oh the deep Metro and crosses the whole thing and some new Metro lines will be built at the sides here, a motorway runs under the whole thing - it's out there in that direction - then a railway line runs right across, and a goods track here, so there's not much left to build on, there's a bit here we can build, there's a bit here we can build on, and then there are a couple of small things here and bits there, it wasn't very nice, but we knew beforehand that it wouldn't be, so that was that, and then there is the advantage that the site has be excavated, there wasn't so much work with the earth, the hole was already there when we came, but the cube should be placed there, and then the civil engineer came out one day and said that if you want it there you will have to turn it 6.5degrees. "Oh", I said, it's, it's every architect's dream to be able to turn his cube 6.5 degrees, isn't it.
It matters that I should be in the same family as the other buildings out here, here is the big exhibition building, here is the Fiat Tower which Skidmore, Owings and Merril were involved with, here are commercial premises and then the high-rise blocks all the way through, Prov has built one of his first tower blocks just down here, and I don't want to stand apart from them, I will still be one of them, but all the same, I will still retain my individuality, so I maintain the same cool architectural style with the smooth glass facades and marble and steel and all that, but I have turned mine through the 6.5 degrees, while all the others a lined up in a row there, the French think that's wonderful too. SPRECKELSEN: I would like twice as much time, but these are the conditions, and that means that all the things you need to find out, what you can do, and the fact that there is so little time, and how much time you can allow yourself to get things done quickly, and here I can say that we are lucky, we have an old-fashioned studio here, and it works in an old-fashioned way, everybody sits with their part of the task, with their rulers and set-squares, and I wander round chatting to them every now and then, and I try and coordinate everything, so the idea of the job as a whole is still there, and the project runs quickly, faster than at home, definitely, but I don't think that any areas are neglected. The thing that allows us to work quickly in practice is that all our drawings are repeated as computer drawings, are treated so that they can be expanded in the large machine, measured, checked that nothing is forgotten, and the drawings are coordinated with the specifications in the quotation material which is already prepared, and of course this can be done very fast, if it all had to be drawn in the old-fashioned way we would have no chance of getting things done in time. So it is, I think, a fine combination of an old-fashioned drawing office, where just one person, me, for example, can supervise everything, and then there are the modern aids which mean that the machine can print it out in, say, 35 copies, all the floors, and correct things much faster and so on. This is good and one of the reasons that we can get things done so quickly. SPRECKELSEN: There is no shadow effect here, and the ceiling is pretty dark all the same. One wants to see the trees disappear there, behind the sky. It's not exactly the most regular. DRAUGHTSMAN: I thought that, er, if Marianne is going to start on some cylinders on this, then it's about 2.80 which can be there, can't it, and it will still be good. SPRECKELSEN: And there you can be very sensible and say the higher they are the greater the chance I will have of getting headspace. And I don't think you're looking at it from the balcony of course and downwards. You won't be able to see it from below. And it is possible that it will be quite exciting to see the different angles, it's only a question of a few degrees, we must maintain a minimum distance and then we can run straight lines down the arch which YOU PUT UP AT HIGH AS POSSIBLE? DRAUGHTSMAN: Yes, yes, of course. We have to go under that one, don't we? SPRECKELSEN: Yes, we have to go under it. Fine, it'll work.
SPRECKELSEN: Of course there are problems with the different way we work, the French like to change things all the time. This is probably because they are individualists, oh you can't work with Frenchmen and they don't expect cooperation either. If I cooperate, it's a sign of weakness on my part. They certainly find it difficult to work with each other, too, because they have different ideas about things and of course it can be inspiring to hear all these things at an early stage in the project since you can see what is happening about you, what does that group think or that person or those two people, and so on, and, oh, it can influence the project and its final design. But when they all want something and changed ideas appear at the end of the project phase it's not much of a pleasure since there are limits as to how many of their justified or unjustified desires you can fulfill. Of course this is irritating and we try to meet all the justified demands, that goes without saying, but that makes the burden of work even greater, and then you must include the rest of the groups, the French engineers must be included, Europorte de Paris, which is my partner here, must be included, and that causes some problems, because then we have the builder who wants one thing and those responsible for the project who have continued with the original project suddenly have to alter it all just before it is supposed to be submitted. This is a problem, a general problem. And then there can be linguistic problems too, we normally speak English which is a foreign language for both of us, so it's as if we are at the same level and there can be misunderstandings in a discussion where I can mean one definite thing with what I have said and where the French assume it still to be an open question after the meeting. On the whole I would say that, er, the French find it difficult to make a decision because they have no common ground on which to take a decision, they like to keep things open in order to take a decision later. This can be quite good in some circumstances, but it's not so easy when a building has to be completed and everything has to be worked out. They also like writing contracts which are a little vague, oh - I can't understand that, I like to have problems cleared up so that the business of the contract is over and done with, but there were several clauses in this contract which were unclear, and where the French said that this was an advantage because then we could talk about it later, and they really mean that, and maybe it's me who's wrong, and since it was a French contract I had to sign, I had to give way on some unclear points and sign, and of course this caused problems later on, which I was sorry about. And then you have to start renegotiating the contract, and we don't have time for that. And of course this causes problems.
SPRECKELSEN: The other artist I work with called, D.e.w.a.s.n.e., as it is spelt, Dewasne is his name, is, er, funny type, a very little man, a very careful man, very wary, doesn't say that much, he goes around quietly and, and, and, it's as if you can't really get through to him, he is very warm, a warm person, and I had my eye on him for a long time. You can see his work hanging in Louisiana, he's the one with the large, geometrical figures, very strong colors, perfectly finished and clear and very controlled, and I told him that I would like to have him on board. What I mostly wanted him for was to do some very large compositions, 100 meters high and interiors 70 meters wide, and there were four large office walls in the building and then there's a hall with a double hall with offices along either side, so that about half of them face the inner room there, and the rest face out to the view there, and these large surfaces are the 70 meter long corridors which are 100 meters high. That is, if you cut a building like this in half, we have 35 hallway walls all the way through, and I wanted him to do a giant painting and cut it into pieces, and I tried to explain this to him and he said, "Yes but can't you - can't you see my compositions from the outside, can't you see my entire picture of 100 times 70 meters?" and I said "No, you can't", and then I thought a bit - and then I said to him "It's in each hallway," I said "it's like a piece of music," I told him, "And you don't experience that all at once either, it can take two hours before you have finished with the music, they are all lines of notes, you write a melody there and then you go through the hallways and gradually experience all the music." "Oh", he said, "that means that no-one will ever see my picture as a whole". So I said "No, they won't." "That sounds interesting", he said, (laughter) He'd understood, and he was so inspired by the idea that a young Dewasne emerged, he, er - because his usual compositions normally can't be cut into pieces, and I was stupid, I said to him "just saw them up", no, you couldn't do that, so now he has found some compositions which can be sawn up, and can be experienced one at a time. It's possible that it will take a few years before you have heard all his music, it doesn't matter, it is possible that you will only come as far as the first movement, or the presto, or the allegretto, it doesn't matter either, everything can be enjoyed as it is, if the music is good, and Dewasne can do that, so he is now working on. He's got a few contracts, where he's making four of these huge compositions which you experience over the course of perhaps 30 years. In one building we have ministerial civil servants and they just go straight up to their office, so it may take 50 years before they see all of it. Up here people change round all the time since they're business people who keep getting a new place and moving higher and higher up, so they have the chance of seeing the whole of his picture in just a few years. I'll be interested to see what happens in the end. But I have some problems with investors, there was one investor who said that he didn't want that because, in the first place, he didn't like Dewasne, and then it was a daft idea to cut the whole thing in pieces, so I dished up that idea about music again, "It's the notes" I said, each movement separate and all that, so he thawed and warmed to the idea, which was strange, but after the meeting the client whispered to me that he sings in the church choir. SPEAKER: In 1986 France had a change of government. The Socialists resigned and were replaced by a right-wing government. The new government withdrew its support for the building project. Dewasne's huge paintings have therefore only been completed in about half of the building. The change of government and other changes concerning the cube caused Spreckelsen to withdraw from the project. SPRECKELSEN: I am more or less finished with Paris, yes, more or less, more or less, but really I should have continued supervising what was going on, according to the contract, but this is difficult to do, so many difficulties arose. So I terminated the contract, and that was probably the best thing I could do, since now I go down there when I want to. When they want me down there, I come, and when I feel like it I go there and advise them, and try to decide things if they have asked for changes, which undeniably happens very often, not least in France, so the conditions under which I'm now working are more pleasant than the conditions laid down in the contract, which couldn't be adhered to by either party.
TSCHERNIA: You couldn't adhere to the contract? SPRECKELSEN: I found it difficult, because when there are so many changes and I have to go down there incessantly, not just only once a month as stipulated in the contract but perhaps five or six times. I mean, you can't adhere to it, it's impossible. I would like to have had it arranged so that all questions were gathered for just one visit, but in practice things suddenly arise where they say, "Now Spreckelsen will have to decide" and I have to fly down the next day, and then it can happen that when I get down there is nothing to decide, so they say that "now you're here, what was it we had to talk about? Oh yes, it wasn't anything special", so I fly home again, and the next day it could be that the same question arises again, which means that I have to constantly travel backwards and forwards, so it would have been better to live down there, but that wasn't the idea, so now I follow progress from a distance, and I think that really it's very good that it turned out this way. TSCHERNIA: Is it the political changes in France which cause things to change all the time, so that everyone is uncertain as regards what they really want from the building? SPRECKELSEN: Yes, they're a major contributing factor. The change in the spring of '86 when they went from a left-wing government to a right-wing government meant that one had to abandon the project as one supported by the state: it was now to be taken over by the private sector. They had to give up the large project concerning an international center for communication, which was the main point of the project and which not only set its architectural stamp on the scheme but which was important as a tourist attraction, thousands of people would have gone out there every day to see what was happening in the field of communication, not only from a technical point of view but also in practice; you could meet people not just from Paris but from all of France, all the world, through those media which have been taken out of the project because the state wouldn't invest in it, and this has given them a lot of problems down there. In the first place they need to find some private investors, and these investors want to do almost anything but communicate, with that system. So some of the project has to be changed, but fortunately not the cube. The cube will be built as planned, and I completed the drawings before I left, so that is continuing as it's supposed TO.
TSCHERNIA: And they're not making any changes to that? SPRECKELSEN: No, only small things are changed, maybe they'll change some interiors, but I should think that they will consult me about what I can accept, possibly they refer to the drawings we supplied and if there are any changes we can see what it is they want changed. TSCHERNIA: But you can be certain that the triumphal arch, or cube, that is being built, will be the way you want it? SPRECKELSEN: Yes, and I can't ask for more, and it will come to resemble the project as I designed it. Of course. There are some things I am sorry about, the fine marble I had chosen, which the President liked and was in the quotation, has not been used, they chose a cheaper marble which is a shame and, for me, not very understandable, they could have chosen the best, it had been reserved in Carrara, it could be mined in one particular place in Carrara, there was enough of it, it was more or less ready, and then they go and choose a cheaper one, to save a few million. You save several millions but I am afraid that the French will regret it. It won't be the fine, good-looking polished marble cube, it will be a bit sad, a bit grey, a bit rough on the surface, and it's a pity. I could also be sorry that they have changed the big pieces of glass which should have been magnificent mirrors on the north and south-facing side, they have found a more ordinary method of suspending the glass, in the ordinary frames which we already known from normal office buildings, which is a bit of a shame for the cube, it won't be so elegant, but it will still look good, it can take these knocks, it can take wearing ordinary working clothes instead of evening dress, it will still be fine. TSCHERNIA: Have you noticed if there is any difference in the way you are treated as a foreigner and the way the French treat each other?
SPRECKELSEN: The French are hard on themselves, very hard on themselves, and I would say that during the time that I was down there they treated me very well. When I say "they" I mean President Mitterand and, er, the people who have been responsible for the project, I have been treated fairly, a lot of people have supported the project. But I couldn't help noticing that there has been a - a distant attitude, they rather resented the fact that I was - that I came from abroad. Of course they would rather have seen a French company. Oh, at the reception, where I was presented with the prize, they were absolutely delighted and I got a fine, fine reception, but the longer you stay the greater the distance. Recently it was easy to feel that it was difficult for them to disguise it, it cropped up more and more that I wasn't one of them, but, oh, they hide it well, they are a polite race.
TSCHERNIA: When it is apparent, how do you notice it? SPRECKELSEN: It becomes apparent in practice when they try to skirt round the architect, and this puts me in a difficult position, because I regard myself as a guest in France, and I have to behave well when I am a guest, had it been at home I could have tackled things differently, but, er, as a foreigner there, there you can't really, I think, in France, and, oh, that's probably one of the reasons that I have pulled out, just in order to prevent an actual break, which would have been a shame for the entire project and for the relationship between me and the French if it had gone so far as a real breach at a personal level. Which it didn't. It came to a breach of contract, but, er, at a person to person level it didn't. I still travel down there, I meet them all, I have, what would you call it, I have, I have seen it before, and er, we have a relationship which is still pleasant and friendly today.
TSCHERNIA: But you can build houses with that, can you? SPRECKELSEN: Yes, that's the only thing you can build houses with. A feeling of mutual trust is,after all, the most important thing, the contract for such a project is unimportant anyway. You have a contract in order to break it, the French love that. Well, I wouldn't actually say they are in direct breach of contract, but they have certainly done their best to sneak round quite a few things, and if you don't have a contract you stand in a better position in some ways, and the - the most important thing is the mutual feeling of trust, and you can easily build houses and monuments with that.
SPRECKELSEN: Oh, it sounds a bit much, a triumphal arch for humanity, but I think it's right to try and tell people that humanity as such really deserves an arch. It's usually individuals who have monuments, and as a rule the bigger the monument the less well known they are. And here it's the big insurance companies and banks who have monuments, so I think it was reasonable to say to people, This is your house, even if it is big and magnificent, it's still something which belongs to you". It's not a monument commemorating something or other, but what it's for, I don't know, let time decide, let the people decide later if it is for humanity or if it is simply a monument to Mitterand and the time he was here.
SPEAKER: A few weeks after this program was made, Spreckelsen fell ill while staying in Paris. He died on 16th March, 1987. The cube was half-finished.
Fully interactive transcript included with film purchase.
Remember to explore
included with your purchase.
Click image to activate Filmscape